DEBRA SCUDIERE

Arbitrator | Mediator

Biography

Debra Scudiere is a veteran trial attorney with nearly 40 years of experience. Debra’s practice has dealt with all areas of civil defense litigation including personal injury and wrongful death, insurance, contracts, sexual harassment claims, medical malpractice, and employment law. Debra’s exemplary work as a successful mediator led to her selection to the National Academy of Distinguished Neutrals.

Debra was appointed to serve as a Judge for the 17th Judicial Circuit in Monongalia County, West Virginia in 2019.  During her tenure as Chief Judge of the Court, Debra served on the Resolution Panel of the West Virginia Mass Litigation Panel by appointment of the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals. Debra’s experiences as a Circuit Judge and a seasoned trial attorney give her the insights and problem-solving skills necessary to successfully resolve complex disputes.

After her service as a Circuit Court Judge, Debra was the Executive Director of the West Virginia Bar Foundation. Debra’s leadership and involvement in the legal community earned her notable awards and honors, including receiving an AV® rating by Martindale-Hubbell. Debra has also been recognized as one of the “Best Lawyers in America” for ADR and one of the “Best Lawyers in Pittsburgh.”

In addition to her legal practice, Debra was elected to serve as a West Virginia State Bar Board of Governors Delegate to the American Bar Association House of Delegates. Debra is also a Past President of the West Virginia State Bar and a Past President of the Southern Conference of Bar Presidents, an organization of Bar Presidents and other Bar leaders from 18 southern states. Additionally, Debra serves as Chair of The West Virginia State Bar’s ADR Committee and was for several years the Chair of the West Virginia Judicial Vacancy Advisory Commission.   

Apart from her legal work and involvement across several professional organizations, Debra is an adjunct instructor at the West Virginia University College of Law, where she teaches Trial Advocacy and Pre-Trial Litigation.

Expertise Areas
Education
  • B.A., West Virginia University, 1976
  • J.D., West Virginia University College of Law, 1982
  • Court Admissions
  • The United States Supreme Court
  • The West Virginia State Bar
  • United States District Court for the Northern District of West Virginia
  • United States District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia
  • Legal Employment
  • Mediator and Arbitrator, Independent, Present
  • Member, Resolution Panel of the West Virginia Mass Litigation Panel, 2021
  • Chief Judge, 17th Judicial Circuit, Monongalia County, West Virginia, 2020
  • Judge, 17th Judicial Circuit, Monongalia County, 2020
  • Managing Member, Kay Casto & Chaney PLLC, 2019
  • Partner, Furbee Amos, Webb & Critchfield, 2001
  • Executive Director, The West Virginia Bar Foundation
  • Membership & Community Involvement
  • Board Member, Rosenbaum Family House, Morgantown, West Virginia
  • Leadership, West Virginia Graduate
  • Past President & Past Chair of the Board of Directors, North Central West Virginia Legal Aid Society
  • Past Member of the Board of Directors, West Virginia Senior Legal Aid, Inc.
  • Board Member, Northern West Virginia Dance Council
  • Past President, Southern Conference of Bar Presidents
  • Past Member, National Conference of Bar Presidents
  • West Virginia State Bar Board of Governors Delegate to the American Bar Association House of Delegates
  • Past President & ADR Committee Chair, The West Virginia State Bar
  • Past Chair, Financial Review Committee, The West Virginia State Bar
  • Past Chair, Defense of the Judiciary Committee, The West Virginia State Bar
  • Past Member, Audit Committee, The West Virginia State Bar
  • Past Chair, West Virginia Judicial Vacancy Advisory Commission
  • Monongalia County Bar Association
  • Publications & Speaking Engagements
  • “Advice from Both the Mediator’s and Advocate’s Perspectives” with Thomas G. Steele, THE WEST VIRGINIA LAWYER, Spring 2022
  • “Other States Can Learn from West Virginia’s Success with Mediation,” THE STATE JOURNAL
  • “Mediation Trends in West Virginia,” THE WEST VIRGINIA LAWYER
  • Various articles in THE WEST VIRGINIA LAWYER While Serving as President of The West Virginia State Bar
  • “Effective Discovery Procedures in West Virginia,” Co-Authored with Guy R. Bucci, Barry Hill, and James McQueen, Jr.
  • “Postsecondary Faculty Members’ Rights of Free Speech,” 9 JOURNAL OF COLLEGE AND UNIVERSITY LAW 85
  • Speaker and Coach, West Virginia State Bar’s Basic and Advanced Mediation Training
  • Speaker and Coach, Magistrate Court Mediation Training
  • Speaker, “Advocacy in Mediation: Strategies That Work” Meritas Litigation and Labor & Employment Section, Orlando Peabody
  • Speaker, “Mediation for Insurance Adjusters" Travelers, Charleston, West Virginia
  • Speaker, “Why Mediations Fail” West Virginia State Bar Annual Meeting
  • Speaker, “Advocacy in Mediation – Top Ten Things That Annoy Your Mediator and Don’t Help Your Case Anyway,” Various Bar Associations
  • Former French and English Teacher, Former Union High School, Union, West Virginia
  • Awards & Rankings
  • Martindale-Hubbell AV Rated
  • WHO’S WHO IN WEST VIRGINIA BUSINESS
  • Fellow, The West Virginia Bar Foundation
  • The Best Lawyers in America, Specialty: Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • The Best Lawyers In Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh Magazine
  • Certificate of Merit for Mediation, The West Virginia State Bar
  • experience

    We use cookies and similar technologies to enable services and functionality on our site and to understand your interaction with our service. By clicking on accept, you agree to our use of such technologies for marketing and analytics. See Privacy Policy